# Scheduling software teardown: coding notes, codebook v2.0 (collected September 26, 2026) The published codes are in coded_v2/. Every number on the page comes from there. ## Coding method and agreement Every one of the 100 answers was coded by two independent AI readers (Claude), each working blind from the published protocol (gold2/READER_PROTOCOL_v2.md). No human coded the answers. Each dictionary brand an answer names gets one of six codes: picked (the answer's own verdict, overall or for a case), recommended (assigned to a stated case or fit, not as the verdict), listed, passing (anchor for comparison, thing to avoid, integration, citation label, payment method), anchor (the brand an alternatives question names), or not_a_mention. The page reports "recommended" at the broad level (picked counts as recommended) and "picked" separately. - Reader vs reader: 98.9% agreement on the six codes, 99.5% at the broad (recommended or not) level. - Codes decided by a third AI reader: 4 (gold2/out/J03.jsonl), listed below. - The v1.6 rules-based first pass (alias and cue-phrase matching) agreed with the final codes on 95.1% at the broad level. The earlier staged coding of this teardown (coded/, codebook v1.5, never published) agreed on 71.0%; it is retired and none of its numbers are used. - Source: gold2/CODED_V2_SUMMARY.md, row scheduling. ## The third reader's decisions - q013 (therapists): Jane App picked. The answer's shortlist names it only as "Jane" for multi-practitioner clinics; one reader had not coded it because the bare name is not an alias. - q063 (Square Appointments alternatives): Setmore listed. It carries attributes ("simple, inexpensive scheduling with a free tier") but no case, unlike the other options in that list. This answer has no pick. - q083 (salons, advice question): Boulevard picked, from the answer's "practical breakdown" that assigns it the premium-salon case. - q086 (sales teams, advice question): Cal.com recommended, not picked. It is a best-fit table row but is absent from the answer's "What I'd choose" section. ## Judgment calls that matter for this category - Calendly as a foil. In q018 and q093 (dental) and q024 (home services) Calendly appears only as the kind of tool to avoid ("rather than a generic Calendly-style scheduler", "rather than generic appointment apps like Calendly"). Both readers code it passing in all three. The answers' own shortlists ("I'd demo these three first", "two I'd investigate first") are picks: NexHealth in q018 and q093, Jobber and Housecall Pro in q024. - Square as a payment processor. In q022, q031, q049 and q051 the only Square match is a list of payment processors Acuity connects to. Both readers code Square Appointments passing there. Answers that pick "Square" for a salon or service business (q012, q052, q072, q083, q085, q092 and others) are coded picked. - Shortened names. "Bookings" in q059 ("I'd generally lean toward Microsoft Bookings" and the closing rule "Microsoft 365 company ... Bookings") and "Jane" in q042 and q013 are read as the brand. With these, q059 and q042 are forks: both brands picked. - Head-to-heads with "Choose it if" sections (q047 Calendly vs Cal.com vs SavvyCal) or "practical rule" lines (q031, q051) make every brand picked. The one head-to-head without a pick is q057 (Chili Piper or Calendly for inbound sales), a short answer that only announces a comparison; both brands are passing. - Catalogs without a verdict. q027 (recruiting interviews), q063 and q077 give each option a fit and then ask the buyer for details; the options are recommended, none is picked. - Different meanings of "scheduling". q003 and q082 (shift scheduling), q006 (job orchestration), q030 (sports round robin) pick nothing from the dictionary. In q082 Calendly, Microsoft Bookings and Google Appointment Schedules are named as examples for the other reading ("that's a completely different set of tools, e.g. ...") and coded listed. - Citation labels. Bookafy (q013, q017), OnceHub (q084) and Appointlet (q090) appear only as bracketed source labels and are coded passing. ## Brands the readers added Both readers can code a dictionary brand the alias list missed. Between them they added 21 codes, 11 distinct brand mentions in five answers: - q061 (Calendly alternatives): a table whose rows name tools by domain (microsoft.com, calendar.google.com, acuityscheduling.com, doodle.com, zoho.com): Microsoft Bookings, Google Calendar Appointment Schedules, Acuity Scheduling, Doodle, Zoho Bookings, all recommended. - q067 (free alternative to Calendly): Google Calendar Appointment Schedules and Zoho Bookings, recommended. - q087 (best value): Acuity Scheduling picked; Motion recommended (usemotion.com row). - q088 (growing startup): HubSpot Meetings picked ("HubSpot scheduler if HubSpot-based sales org"). - q013 (therapists): Jane App, added by one reader and confirmed by the third. ## Dictionary notes that still apply The 50-brand dictionary was not changed after collection (decisions in INPUT_NOTES.md). - Square Appointments matches bare "Square" (capitalized only). The readers separate Square as a product pick from Square as a payment processor (above). - HubSpot Meetings does not match bare "HubSpot", and Google Calendar Appointment Schedules does not match bare "Google Calendar", because most answers name both as integrations. An answer that picks plain "HubSpot" (q069 and q076 list it; out_of_dictionary.csv) is not credited. - Out-of-dictionary names that came up: Mangomint (salons and spas), Zenoti, dental practice software (Dentrix, Curve Dental, Open Dental, Weave), recruiting software (GoodTime, Greenhouse, Ashby, Lever, Workable) in q027, fitness studio software (WellnessLiving, Momence, Punchpass), employee shift schedulers (Homebase, When I Work, Deputy, Sling, 7shifts) in q003 and q082, orchestration tools in q006. None would change the leaders. - Case-sensitive aliases (capitalized only): square, doodle, motion, reclaim, clockwise, boulevard, clio, amelia, acuity, jobber. Amelia and Clockwise never appear. - Shared domains: google.com, microsoft.com, zoho.com, hubspot.com, squareup.com and wix.com each count as the own site of the one dictionary brand its parent company makes. Citation findings are unchanged by the re-coding.